Skip to main content

30-to-90 Day Subscription Upgrade Playbook

This playbook walks you through how to move subscribers from a 30-day to a 90-day subscription cadence using Stay's custom workflows — and why it's worth doing.

T
Written by Timothy Fraser

Why upgrade customers from 30 to 90 days?

When a customer upgrades from a 30-day to a 90-day supply, they're committing to a larger recurring order that ships less frequently. Here's why that matters:

  • Fewer cancel opportunities: less frequent shipments mean fewer moments where a customer has to actively decide whether to stay subscribed

  • Lower shipping costs: fewer fulfillments per customer per year

  • Better product results: for products that need 60-90 days to show their full effect (like supplements), a 90-day supply gives customers the runway they need to actually experience the value of their subscription, making them far more likely to stick around


Which upgrade path is right for you?

Use Post-Purchase Upsell if: You want to present the upgrade offer immediately after checkout, before the customer leaves your store.

Use Quick Actions if: You want to reach existing subscribers who didn't convert at checkout through an email, a portal banner, or a cancel survey.

Using Aftersell? Checkout our Aftersell Quarterly Upsell guide here.


1. Post-Purchase Upsell

Is this right for you?

Use this path if you want to present a 90-day upgrade offer immediately after a customer completes checkout.

Prerequisites

Before setting up your Post-Purchase offer, confirm the following:

1. Choose your platform
​

Decide which platform you'll use to power the Post-Purchase offer. If you're using Aftersell, ensure the order tag applied to accepted offers is set to aftersell_upgrade. If you're using a different platform, confirm whether it applies an order tag automatically. If not, you may need a Shopify Function to assign a custom tag.

2. Define your upsell product
​

Determine what the upsell offer will be: an increase in quantity of the same product, or a swap to a different product ID (such as a larger pack size). This will affect how the offer is configured and how the resulting subscription is updated.

3. Choose when the upsell applies

Determine if the upsell will apply on the current order (swapping the product on the order via Aftersell), or should apply on the next order.

What to build in Stay

  1. Navigate to the Subscription Setup -> Workflows section of the application

  2. Configure a Workflow with the following:

    1. Trigger: A Subscription Order is Updated

    2. Condition: Order Contains Tag

      1. Order Tag is typically "aftersell_upgrade"

    3. Action 1: Change Billing Interval to 90 Days

    4. Action 2:

      1. If you are swapping to a higher quantity of the same product, use Change Quantity

      2. If you are swapping to a larger pack size as a different product, use Swap Item

    5. Action 3:

      1. If the upsell fires the larger pack size on the initial order, use Change Next Billing Date

        • Use the Relative type, and set the value to 60 days. This will delay the initial next order date for the 30 day subscription by 60 days, ensuring the customer receives their next order in 90 days.

NOTE: If the upsell fires on the next order, Action 3 is not necessary.

What happens after a customer accepts

Once configured, Stay's workflow triggers automatically when a customer accepts the post-purchase offer and executes the following:

  1. Updates the subscription frequency to every 90 days

  2. Swaps the product or adjusts quantity (based on your upgrade method)

  3. If action 3 is set: Changes the next billing date to by 90 days from their order date

For example

A supplement brand offers a 90-day supply upgrade at 55% off at checkout. When a customer accepts, Stay automatically swaps the hero product to the 3x refill SKU and updates the frequency to every 90 days. The current order will fire as is, and they'll receive the quarterly subscription on their next order.

The same workflow structure can support variations — like a 60-day, 180-day, or a second 90-day offer with a different discount — all built on the same foundation.


2. Mid-Lifecycle Upgrade using Quick Actions (Portal or Email-Triggered)

Is this right for you?

Use this path if you want to upgrade existing subscribers who didn't convert at checkout through a Klaviyo email, a portal banner, or a cancel survey.

What to build in Stay

  1. Your Upgrade Quick Action

    1. If you are increasing the quantity of product:

      1. Navigate to Optimization -> URL Builder

      2. Action 1: Update Quantity

        • Set the value to the appropriate number of products for the given timeframe.

      3. Action 2: Change Frequency

        • Set the value to 90 days, or whatever timeframe applies to the upsell

      4. Optional Action 3 to add a discount code, or fire a Get it Now

    1. If you are swapping to a larger pack size

      1. Navigate to Optimization -> URL Builder

      2. Action 1: Swap Item

        • Set the value from the current product, to the updated larger pack size

      3. Action 2: Change Frequency

        • Set the value to 90 days, or whatever timeframe applies to the upsell

      4. Optional Action 3 to add a discount code, or fire a Get it Now

Next, determine where you want this quick action to live. The links can be copied as-is, used via a QR Code, or embedded in the Cancel Survey or in the portal using dynamic banner ads.

Using Dynamic Banners for Upsells

You can create targeted banners to unlock upsells within the customer portal using Segmentation, and Quick Actions.

  1. Set up your Segment to target the 30 day product

    1. If you are increasing the quantity of the product:

      1. Segment by "Frequency Is 30 Days" AND Line Item Quantity IS 1

    2. If you are swapping to a larger pack size

      1. Segment by "Frequency IS 30 Days" AND "Product ID is [X]"

  2. Create your upsell banner(s)

  3. Set the action for the banner to "Quick Action" and select your upsell quick action from the list

    1. If you are using swaps, make sure you are associating the correct banner to the correct segment to ensure customers are swapping from and to the correct products

Using Upsells in the Cancel survey

Upsell quick actions can be effectively used to combat the cancel reason "I have too much" or "I receive too many shipments". You can use this strategy easily in Stay.

  1. Set up your Segment to target the 30 day product

    1. If you are increasing the quantity of the product:

      1. Segment by "Frequency Is 30 Days" AND Line Item Quantity IS 1

    2. If you are swapping to a larger pack size

      1. Segment by "Frequency IS 30 Days" AND "Product ID is [X]"

  2. Configure your Cancel Survey flow

    1. Navigate to Optimization > Cancel Survey

    2. Create a Save Offer using a Custom URL, and add in your Quick Action

    3. Target your "I have too much" or "I receive too many shipments" cancel reasons

    4. Segment your node based on your previously created segments

    5. Select the Save Offer you created with the upsell Quick Action

What happens after a customer accepts

When a customer clicks a Quick Action via any of the paths listed above, Stay executes the paths outlined when the Quick Action was built. This typically looks like:

  1. Updates the subscription frequency to every 90 days

  2. Swaps the product or adjusts quantity (based on your upgrade method)

  3. Applies a discount code (if configured)

  4. Get it Now (if configured)

Recommended channels to trigger this flow:

  • Klaviyo email campaign — targeted outreach to your active 30-day subscriber segment

  • Customer portal banner — surface the offer to subscribers managing their account

  • Cancel survey — if a customer cites price as a reason for canceling, the bulk savings of a 90-day supply can be a compelling reason to stay

For example

You send a Klaviyo email to your 30-day subscribers offering an upgrade to a quarterly supply for an additional 15% off. When a customer clicks the Quick Action link, they are swapped to the quarterly product, changed to a 90 day frequency, and gets a 15% off discount. The order fires with the 90 day product, and the next billing date will automatically reflect their updated 90 day frequency, ensuring the customer is receiving the correct amount of product for the correct time frame.


3. Variant-Based Frequency Sync

Is this right for you?

Use this path if your products are named by supply duration (e.g. "1-Month Box" vs. "3-Month Box") and a subscriber swapping variants on their existing subscription should automatically update their billing frequency to match.

What to send to Stay

Contact your customer success team with:

  • The variant IDs for each duration-based SKU

  • Which frequency each variant should map to

What happens after a subscriber swaps variants

Stay's workflow listens for the variant swap on an existing subscription and automatically updates the subscription frequency to match — no manual intervention needed.

For example

A brand sells a "1-Month Box" and a "3-Month Box." A subscriber edits their subscription and selects the 3-Month Box variant. Stay detects the swap and updates the subscription frequency to every 90 days, keeping their billing cadence in sync with their selection.


Ready to get started?

There are a lot of ways to configure these upgrades depending on your products and tech stack, so don't worry about having it all figured out before you reach out. Contact your Stay success team with as much detail as you have and we'll make sure you're set up the right way. To help us get started, we'll need:

  • The product/variant ID(s) involved in the upgrade

  • Your upgrade method: frequency change, product swap, quantity change, or a combination

  • For Quick Actions: which channel(s) you plan to use

  • For Variant-Based Frequency Sync: which frequency each variant should map to

Did this answer your question?