There are three main reasons why recurring customer orders may fail:
Payment Method Failures
Shopify Errors
Inventory Issues
In this article, we’ll focus on the first two causes — Payment Method Failures and Shopify Errors.
If you’d like to learn more about managing inventory-related issues, check out our article: 👉 How to Set Up Your Billing and Inventory Settings
Adding A New Payment Method
Stay now allows merchants to give customers a simpler way to update their payment method — without navigating through Shopify’s standard flow.
Benefits of This Update
This improved flow helps customers succeed in several ways:
Seamless Experience: Customers can securely add a new payment method directly within the Stay portal.
Fewer Steps: No need to go through Shopify’s “Update Payment Method” email flow.
Shop Pay Workaround: Bypasses common Shop Pay errors by generating a new, valid payment method ID.
How It Works for Customers
Access the Customer Portal
Customers can open the Edit Payment Method modal in their portal.
Add a New Payment Method
By clicking “Add New Payment Method” button, the customer will be directed to a secure Add Credit Card form.Automatic Update and Retry
Once saved, Stay AI automatically updates the payment method ID on the subscription.
The customer’s next billing attempt will then be charged to the newly added credit card.
Need More Help?
For additional support or troubleshooting tips, visit our Billing FAQ or reach out to your Stay customer success representative.

